Scholarly vs. Popular Periodicals

News magazines and journals

What's the difference between a periodical, a journal, and a magazine?

What difference does it make which one I use?

A "periodical" is any publication that comes out regularly or occasionally TV Guide, Sports Illustrated, The Journal of Anthropological Research, The World Almanac, and the phone book are all periodicals.(i.e. periodically, get it?).

A "magazine" is a periodical with a popular focus, i.e. aimed at the general public, and containing news, personal narratives, and opinion. Articles are often written by professional writers with or without expertise in the subject; they contain "secondary" discussion of events, usually with little documentation (e.g. footnotes). Magazines use vocabulary understandable to most people, and often have lots of eye-catching illustrations. Time, Newsweek, U.S. News & World Report and Psychology Today are magazines.

A "journal" is a scholarly periodical aimed at specialists and researchers. Articles are generally written by experts in the subject, using more technical language. They contain original research, conclusions based on data, footnotes or endnotes, and often an abstract or bibliography. The Journal of Physical Chemistry, The Chaucer Review, The Milbank Quarterly

It's important to understand the differences between journals and magazines. Magazines are not necessarily bad or low quality (nor are journals necessarily high quality) -- they simply aren't designed to support most upper-level academic research. This is because they don't document their sources of information, and they generally lack the depth of scholarly journals.

The table below highlights the differences.

Journals - Scholarly

Magazines - Popular

Content

Detailed report or original research or experiment.

Secondary report or discussion; may include personal narrative, opinion, anecdotes

Author

Author’s credentials are given; usually a scholar with subject expertise

Author may or may not be named; often a professional writer; may or may not have subject expertise.

Audience

Scholars, researchers, and students

General public; the interested non-specialist

Peer-reviewed

Usually

No

Language

Specialized terminology or jargon of the field; requires prior knowledge

Vocabulary in general usage; understandable to most readers

Layout & Organization

Formal organization often begins with an abstract of the article; if reporting experimental findings notes the experiment’s purpose, methodology, and analysis of the results; a conclusion, and a bibliography; may include charts or graphs, but rarely photographs.

Informal organization: eye-catching type and formatting, usually includes illustrations or photographs. May not intend to present an idea with supporting evidence or come to a conclusion

Bibliography & References

Required. All quotes and facts can be verified.

Rare. Very little, if any, information about sources.

Examples

Developmental Psychology
JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association

The words "journal" or "review" often appear in the title.

Harper’s
Newsweek
People
Time

Almost anything available in a store or news stand


* Scholar’s work is reviewed by experts in the field

Information from University of Michigan-Flint’s LibAnswers: http://libanswers.umflint.edu/a.php?qid=213617

The following video from Peabody Library, Vanderbilt University, provides a quick review:
Website by SchoolMessenger Presence. © 2017 West Corporation. All rights reserved.